Caramel Custard

A Simple Homestead - Caramel Custard

I have been reluctant to show this recipe.   Certainly not because it’s not very good.  Because it is.  Too good!  No, it’s because it took multiple attempts to get a good picture of the final product.  I tried several times.  Which means Papa has made several batches of this recently (as my scale would indicate).

Custard still in the ramekin is “ok”, but it doesn’t show the best part!

caramel custard - ramekin

While a partially filled bowl gives you a view of the goodness that lies beneath … it doesn’t look very appetizing.

caramel custard - large ramekin

Scooped out into a bowl looks pretty good.

caramel custard in a bowl

And then there is this one…

caramel custard - all gone

Whoops! I guess Mama got to that one before the picture was taken.

Here we go … this one turned out pretty tasty looking!

A Simple Homestead - Caramel Custard

Frankly though, it doesn’t matter what the custard looks like…  If you have eggs, you need to make this today!

To be honest, Papa used to make this occasionally after we were first married and I ate it but didn’t think much of it.  Or maybe it’s because sometimes he made as caramel custard, sometimes put the sugar on top after it baked (that’s called creme brulee, people!), and sometimes I think he made it just plain.  Then a few years ago, I got pregnant.   Papa just happened to make this one evening … and for some reason I was hooked.  Apparently for life.  He ended up making it several times until Little Chick’s birth, at my request – but it’s easier than making midnight trips to the store for pickles and ice cream.

This dessert is so easy.  Our original recipe came from our trusted 1950’s Betty Crocker, but of course we had to change it up a bit. The recipe had this cute little poem to go with it:

caramel custard poem

I like them warm … or cold, if they last that long.  Spooned from the cup is just easier for me … and saves on dirtying a plate.   If you eat them right away (which I have often done), some of the caramelized sugar will be like hard candy stuck to the bottom of the bowl.  If you want to lick out the bottom of the dish, it’s best to save yourself some embarrassment and attempt it when you don’t have company over.  However, if you let it sit overnight … I know, it’s so hard … ALL that caramel goodness will turn to liquid and become a lovely sauce for your custard!

Caramel Custard

Cook Time30 minutes
Servings: 6


  • 1/2 cup plus 1/3 cup sugar
  • 3 eggs
  • 1/4 teaspoon salt
  • 2 cups milk
  • 1 teaspoon real vanilla extract
  • a sprinkle of ground nutmeg


  • Grease your ramekins or casserole and place them into an oven-safe pan. Preheat the oven to 350°F.
  • Melt the 1/2 cup of sugar in a small pan over low heat, stirring until it turns brown. Pour a little into each cup and swirl the cups around so it coats the entire bottom.
  • Beat slightly the eggs, 1/3 cup sugar and salt.
  • In a medium saucepan, heat the 2 cups of milk and nutmeg until a film forms on top (this is scalding the milk). Slowly pour the heated milk into the egg mixture, stirring constantly so the eggs don’t become scrambled. Stir in the vanilla.
  • Pour the egg custard mixture over the caramelized sugar in the ramekins. Pour hot water into the oven-proof pan on the outside of the ramekins, so it comes up the sides about 1″. This will help steam the custard.
  • Bake at 350°F for 30 to 35 minutes or until a knife inserted in the center comes out clean. Remove the ramekins from the hot water.
  • Serve warm or cold. To unmold, run a knife along the inside edge of the ramekin. Place a plate over the top of the ramekin, and firmly holding both in your hands, flip them over so the plate is on the bottom and the custard should slip out.


You will need six 4-ounce custard cups (ramekins) or a 1 1/2-quart casserole dish.

6 Replies to “Caramel Custard”

  1. If my oven hadn’t stopped working, I’d be trying this recipe right NOW!

    1. I hope it starts working soon!

  2. really? it’s that’s simple?! hmmmm 🙂

  3. Oh it looks delicious….an wonderful way to Thrive at Home. Homemade Custard!!

  4. This looks so yummy! Thanks for sharing with the Thrive @ Home Thursday link-up. This recipe will be featured on this week’s link-up post!

  5. Thrive at Home Thursday {Link-Up} :: 4.3.2014 - Gospel Homemaking says: Reply

    […] Caramel Custard Shared by Carmen at A Simple Homestead   […]

Leave a Reply

Recipe Rating